What happens when someone has survived an abusive relationship, rebuilt a life, and moved beyond anger but has never forgiven the person responsible? Is that recovery incomplete, or has the person found a way forward that deserves to be recognized on its own terms?
Dr. Diane Pomerantz raises these questions in her Psychology Today essay Is Forgiveness Necessary for Healing? A psychologist with more than four decades of clinical experience and the author of Lost in the Reflecting Pool: Surviving Narcissistic Emotional Abuse, she challenges the expectation that forgiveness must be part of everyone's recovery from abuse.
When Forgiveness Becomes Another Demand
Advice about forgiveness often comes from a compassionate intention. Friends, family members, and even professionals may encourage someone to release resentment because they believe holding on to anger will prolong suffering.
Dr. Pomerantz questions the pressure created by that belief. Someone who has already experienced abuse may find themselves facing another judgment: unless they forgive, they have somehow failed to overcome what happened.
In her essay, she examines the consequences of turning forgiveness into a universal moral obligation. The individual who endured the harm becomes responsible for reaching an approved emotional state, regardless of the behavior of the person who caused it.
For someone emerging from an abusive relationship, this expectation can be particularly difficult. The experience may already have involved years of accommodating another person's demands, minimizing personal feelings, or assuming responsibility for keeping the peace.
Dr. Pomerantz describes the confusion that can develop when someone has repeatedly questioned whether they have been mistreated. An insistence on forgiveness can add to that uncertainty, especially when the abusive person continues denying responsibility.
Her concern is whether the expectation serves the person recovering from abuse. She believes the answer depends on what forgiveness means, what happened in the relationship, and whether the person responsible has acknowledged the injury.
The Place of Remorse and Responsibility
Dr. Pomerantz understands forgiveness as a relational process involving both the person who was harmed and the person who caused the harm. In her account, genuine forgiveness includes acknowledgment of wrongdoing, remorse, and a willingness to make amends.
She draws on philosophical discussions of forgiveness, including the work of Alice MacLachlan and Maria Mayo. Their examinations of wrongdoing, responsibility, and the limits of forgiveness inform her argument that the moral circumstances surrounding an injury deserve serious consideration.
An apology carries greater significance when the person offering it recognizes what happened. The willingness to listen, accept responsibility, and respond to the injured person's experience creates the possibility of meaningful reconciliation.
That process becomes much harder when the wrongdoer denies the behavior or expects the injured person to move on without acknowledgment. Dr. Pomerantz questions what an instruction to forgive accomplishes under those circumstances.
She is particularly critical of advice that combines forgetting, forgiving, and moving on into one apparently simple solution. Emotional abuse may involve repeated manipulation, criticism, and the gradual erosion of personal boundaries, all of which require time to understand.
The person who caused the harm remains responsible for that behavior. Dr. Pomerantz believes that requiring forgiveness without addressing this responsibility risks placing another burden on someone who has already suffered.
Her essay also acknowledges the importance of genuine forgiveness in human relationships. She values the capacity to forgive, while questioning whether every injury calls for the same response or whether forgiveness is always appropriate.
Why Being the Peacemaker Can Become a Pattern
Dr. Pomerantz describes how people experiencing emotional abuse may become accustomed to maintaining peace at considerable personal cost. They may avoid difficult conversations, overlook troubling behavior, or hesitate to set boundaries because disagreement has become emotionally exhausting.
Over time, these accommodations can affect a person's confidence in their own judgment. Someone may recognize that an interaction feels harmful yet question whether they have the right to object.
The pattern creates a particular difficulty when forgiveness becomes another expectation. A person who has spent years yielding to another's demands may once again feel pressure to put personal feelings aside.
Dr. Pomerantz's reflections return to the importance of understanding how such patterns develop. She encourages examination of the decisions, emotional needs, and vulnerabilities that influenced a person's responses within the relationship.
That examination requires compassion. Recognizing why someone struggled to establish limits can help explain their experience without assigning them responsibility for another person's abusive conduct.
The work can continue after separation. Habits developed during a harmful relationship may influence later choices, making reflection valuable even when contact with the former partner has ended.
In Dr. Pomerantz's view, understanding these patterns offers an opportunity to make different choices in the future. The work involves learning to recognize one's own needs, trust personal perceptions, and respond more confidently when boundaries are challenged.
Understanding and Acceptance in Her Own Recovery
Dr. Pomerantz's perspective developed through her experience of an emotionally abusive marriage. Her memoir, Lost in the Reflecting Pool: Surviving Narcissistic Emotional Abuse, recounts the relationship and her gradual recognition of how profoundly it had affected her identity.
She had extensive professional knowledge of psychology, yet her personal attachments and circumstances made the marriage difficult to understand while she was living through it. Love, shared history, serious illness, and family responsibilities formed part of the experience she later examined.
Writing became central to that examination. Initially, her manuscript was an expression of pain and anguish, but over time she began using the writing to understand events and their place within her larger life story.
As her perspective developed, she became less consumed by the emotions associated with the marriage. She was able to revisit the experiences with greater distance and consider the choices she had made without remaining trapped in the feelings of the earlier period.
In her Psychology Today essay, Dr. Pomerantz states, “I have moved on and am no longer angry.” She then explains that forgiveness is not the word she would use to describe that experience.
Understanding and acceptance are the terms she chooses. She came to recognize what had happened, examine her responses, and integrate those experiences into her understanding of herself.
Her position is grounded in that personal history. She describes a meaningful change in her emotional life without attributing the change to an act of forgiveness toward her former husband.
The Difference Between Acceptance and Approval
Acceptance can be difficult to understand when the experience involved emotional abuse. The word may suggest agreement with what happened, particularly to someone who spent years trying to minimize or excuse another person's behavior.
Dr. Pomerantz uses acceptance in connection with understanding the past as it occurred. She can acknowledge the experience and its effects while continuing to recognize the harm she endured.
This requires examining painful memories without expecting them to become pleasant or acceptable. A person may acknowledge that a relationship included loving experiences while also recognizing behavior that was destructive.
For Dr. Pomerantz, the process involved reconsidering choices she had once found difficult to understand. She examined why she had overlooked certain behaviors, how she had responded to conflict, and what she might do differently in future relationships.
The questions carry a different purpose from assigning blame. They direct attention toward self-understanding and the ability to make informed decisions rather than toward punishment for choices made under difficult circumstances.
Acceptance can also change the place an experience occupies in someone's life. The past remains part of personal history, but it no longer needs to determine every response to the present.
This is the emotional movement Dr. Pomerantz describes in her memoir and later essay. She found a way to understand the experience and continue living without making forgiveness a requirement.
Giving Recovery Its Own Meaning
Dr. Pomerantz's argument leaves room for different experiences of recovery. Some people may find genuine forgiveness meaningful, particularly when wrongdoing has been acknowledged and relationships can be reconsidered responsibly.
Others may find that understanding, acceptance, and establishing personal boundaries provide a more appropriate way forward. Their progress can involve recognizing harmful patterns, developing confidence, and building relationships that support their independence.
The question of forgiveness may change over time, just as a person's understanding of a relationship can change. Dr. Pomerantz resists prescribing a single emotional destination because the circumstances surrounding abuse and recovery are deeply personal.
Her perspective also reflects a broader concern in her psychological work: the importance of understanding people within the context of their own histories. An individual's response to painful experiences cannot be fully understood through a single rule about what recovery should look like.
The expanded second edition of Lost in the Reflecting Pool develops the memoir's psychological perspective through additional material about emotionally abusive relationships. Readers encounter that discussion alongside the personal experiences through which Dr. Pomerantz came to understand her marriage differently.
Her refusal to make forgiveness compulsory is part of a continuing examination of personal responsibility, emotional vulnerability, and the possibility of change. It encourages people to think carefully about what moving forward means within their own circumstances.
Moving Forward Without a Required Act of Forgiveness
Dr. Diane Pomerantz's reflections offer a thoughtful challenge to the belief that survivors of emotional abuse must forgive before they can recover. Her experience shows how self-understanding, acceptance, and the ability to make different choices can shape a meaningful life after abuse.
Read Lost in the Reflecting Pool: Surviving Narcissistic Emotional Abuse to discover the personal history behind her perspective on forgiveness, responsibility, and emotional recovery.





